In the days since Graham’s death, our era of paranoid politics has produced a string of theories online: he died in Kyiv. He was taken out by Israel. He was poisoned by Iran. He was blown up by Russia.
In a statement, Graham’s office said on Sunday that preliminary findings from the Washington DC medical examiner’s office found he suffered an aortic dissection. A death certificate remains pending. Authorities have not indicated foul play.
Still, an algorithm-fuelled online ecosystem is once again abuzz, the internet’s reactionary machinery churning at full force with suspicions about the health of not one but two prominent senators and the forces shielding the American people from the truth.
Senator Mitch McConnell’s office on Sunday released a statement that his hospitalisation last month was caused by a fall, providing the first detailed update after weeks of silence.
A photograph of the Kentucky Republican accompanied the statement, showing him sitting in a hospital bed, a smile stretched across his face, his wife at his bedside. In his hand, a copy of that day’s Washington Post sports section. That did nothing to dissuade the online commentariat.
“Why does the text on the newspaper McConnell’s staff claim he’s holding look AI generated?” Loomer posted on X.
One X account shared, without evidence, that the picture was actually from 2023 in a post that has since amassed some 5.1 million views in less than 24 hours.
Other accounts began asking X’s Grok chatbot to analyse the photo for inconsistencies. “Appears to be a genuine photo,” the bot replied to one such query. To another, however, it fanned scepticism of the original photo: “The ‘proof of life’ claim doesn’t hold up here.”
On Monday, The Post examined that metadata from the photo and it did indeed appear to have been taken on Sunday, and a digital forensics expert told the paper he saw no evidence of AI or other manipulation.
Joseph Uscinski, a political scientist at the University of Miami and leading researcher of public opinion and conspiracy theories, has found scant evidence that beliefs in conspiracy theories are increasing in the current era. “Things aren’t getting worse. That’s the good news,” he said. “The bad news is things have always been pretty bad. We just weren’t paying attention.”
But what’s changed in our online age is that conspiracy theorists are both better mobilised and more tightly woven into the fabric of our current political apparatus. Views that once would have been confined by the hard material reality of spreading information by pamphlet or radio broadcast are now encountered within seconds by any and everyone thanks to social media.
In Trump’s Washington, the chasm between the parallel universes of verified facts and of disproved theories can collapse. The president, for example, centred his early political career around baseless claims about Barack Obama’s place of birth and has continued to espouse falsehoods that the 2020 election was stolen.
“Mixed within these online conspiracy theories are also people who want and deserve the truth,” said Joan Donovan, a Boston University professor who has extensively studied misinformation and media manipulation. “And unfortunately, the government hasn’t earned enough of the public trust to be the final arbiters of that.”
Asked on Monday about those who doubt the official explanations of Graham’s death and McConnell’s extended absence from the Capitol Hill, Senate Majority Leader John Thune said “there’s so much noise in the world today”. He continued: “I hope that people can calm down and just mourn the loss.”
A stanch defender of Ukraine, Graham died hours after returning from his 10th wartime trip to the country since Russia’s 2022 invasion. Sceptics, right-wing provocateurs and others that were quick to point out the timeline. After all, Russia under Vladimir Putin has a well-documented history of killing political “dissidents” at home and abroad.
Overseas, Russian state media pundits and propagandists have met the news of Graham’s death with a mix of vitriol and conspiracy theories that link his passing to his advocacy for Ukraine. A Russian tabloid published a piece titled “The Kiss of Death: Senator Graham’s Death Linked to Zelensky,” in which a political analyst promoted a conspiracy that “many officials” who come into contact with Zelensky either resign or die.
Last Monday, five days before his death, Graham shared footage online from Ali Khamenei’s recent funeral in Tehran of people caring signs with his face, along with others including Trump’s and Loomer’s. “At least they used a good photo of me. Judge me by my enemies,” Graham shared on X.
In the footage, the signs displayed Graham’s and the others with a target on their forehead and the text: “Sooner or later, your heads will roll.”
“Why would someone not take those threats seriously?” Loomer said to The Post.
Patel, the FBI director, hasn’t posted on X about Graham since Sunday. DC police are the law enforcement department that leads death investigations in the District, and a department spokesperson on Monday declined to say whether DC police had requested extra assistance from the FBI. A spokesperson for the FBI declined to clarify the scope of the agency’s involvement.
But on Monday afternoon, NBC News reported that officers from the FBI were spotted at Graham’s DC residence on Monday. It didn’t take long for Loomer to update her online base. “I didn’t realize 20 FBI agents were needed to convince everyone that Lindsey Graham died from an Aortic Dissection,” she posted on X. “Did the toxicology report come back? 2 things can be true at once.”
– Mary Ilyushina, Theodoric Meyer, Matthew Choi and Luke Connors contributed to this report.
