Don’t know about you but I have arrived at the quiet truth that most adults discover and never say out loud: birthdays, for a significant portion of the population, are not the dazzling celebration the world insists they should be.
Let me be clear about what this is not. It has nothing to do with getting older. No, really. I have long since made my peace with the accumulation of years. In fact, I’d argue that kind of anxiety is deeply overrated and largely a construct sold to us by the beauty industry. The number doesn’t bother me in the slightest. What bothers me is the expectation.
Somewhere along the way, birthdays stopped being a simple acknowledgment that you’d survived another trip around the sun and became a full-scale production.
A day that is supposed to arrive draped in flowers, gifts, champagne, cake and people who love you – a day that is supposed to feel different from every other day. And when it doesn’t – when it feels like a Wednesday (because it is, in fact, a Wednesday) the gap between what you were promised and what you actually get can be quietly crushing.
This is where the great birthday divide sits. There are two kinds of people in this world: Those who love their birthday with the unguarded enthusiasm of a golden retriever puppy begin the countdown in early January, while the other lot would genuinely prefer if the whole thing passed without incident – like a scheduled 3am phone update that doesn’t interrupt anything.
Neither camp is right or wrong, but the world is largely built for the first group, which makes it quietly uncomfortable to those who belong to the second.
The loneliness of a low-key birthday is something nobody really talks about. Especially when you’re single. When you’re partnered up, there’s usually someone who makes the quiet version of the day feel intentional rather than accidental – a nice dinner, a small gesture, the sense that someone remembered.
When you’re on your own, you wake up on your birthday to the world’s most loaded question: so, “what are you doing today, no doubt something fabulous?” And the answer, “honestly, probably nothing” feels like a confession rather than a choice.
Social media has made all of this significantly worse. The birthday celebration post has become a genre of its own with a curated highlight reel of flowers from an impressive number of admirers and restaurants that know how to do good celebration.
The very thoughtful birthday wishes from LinkedIn contacts kind of sinks the celebratory boot in even more. This year and by 7am, 15 lovely people I’d never met had wished me happy birthday while Gerald from accounts payable at a company I’ve never heard of was my first well-wisher. I chose not to examine the optics of that too closely.
We’ve turned birthdays into performance art, and then we feel vaguely ashamed when our own doesn’t make the cut.
There’s also a particular cruelty in the expectation that you will be radiant and available and full of joy on command. That you will want to gather people together, that you will want to be looked at. Some of us find that exhausting on our best days so being told it’s mandatory because of a calendar date doesn’t help.
What I’ve come to appreciate, belatedly and without apology, is the non-monumental age birthday that passes calmly and quietly.
The one where a few people who matter send a message that doesn’t require a response, where nobody expects anything, where you can eat whatever you want for dinner and watch something self-indulgent and go to bed at a reasonable hour. No fanfare. No production. Just a day.
And the moment the clock ticks over to the following morning, and it’s done for another year? There’s genuine, deep, unironic relief. If that makes me a birthday Scrooge, I’m comfortable with the label.
Truth is, I’m slightly embarrassed anyone would want to make a fuss in the first place as everyone’s got their own lives unravelling in real time, so the idea that they’d pause that to celebrate “me” is one mighty big ask. And I have a strong suspicion there are more of us out there than birthday posts would have us believe.
Melissa Hoyer is a social commentator.
Get a weekly wrap of views that will challenge, champion and inform your own. Sign up for our Opinion newsletter.
