LATEST
তালতলীতে বিয়ের দাবিতে প্রেমিকের বাড়িতে ৫ সন্তানের জননীর অনশন Kiwi powerlifters Megan-Li Smith and Karlina Tongotea in big-money global contest খুলনায় বিএনপি নেতাকে গুলি সাবেক স্বাস্থ্যমন্ত্রীর বাড়ির সামনে পার্কিং করা বাসে আগুন Dave Rennie faces scrutiny after All Blacks’ record defeat to England Man dies hanging Christmas lights in London shopping centre ক্ষমতাকেন্দ্রিক সহিংস রাজনীতি মানুষকে বিপর্যয়ের দিকে ঠেলে দিচ্ছে: সিপিবি সশস্ত্র বাহিনী দিবস জাতীয় জীবনের গৌরবোজ্জ্বল দিন: অর্থ ও পরিকল্পনামন্ত্রী আমির খসরু
Sports

All Blacks v England players ratings: How Davie Rennie’s side rated in Twickenham flop

All Blacks v England players ratings: How Davie Rennie’s side rated in Twickenham flop
Premium
Opinion
All Blacks v England players ratings: How Davie Rennie’s side rated in Twickenham flop
Winston Aldworth
Opinion by

Head of Sport·NZ Herald·
21 Nov, 2026 06:09 PM8 mins to read
Winston Aldworth is Head of Sport for NZME, working alongside New Zealand’s best sports journalists in the radio and publishing teams.
‌

Subscribe to listen

Access to Herald Premium articles require a Premium subscription. Subscribe now to listen.Subscribe now

Already a subscriber?  Sign in here

Listening to articles is free for open-access content—explore other articles or learn more about text-to-speech.
‌
Gift article

Save

Share

    Share this article

    Reminder, this is a Premium article and requires a subscription to read.

  • Copy Link
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter/X
  • LinkedIn
  • Reddit
Dejected All Blacks at full time. Photo / Photosport

Dejected All Blacks at full time. Photo / Photosport

How the All Blacks rated in their 37-12 defeat to England.

1. Ethan de Groot – 5

Was found at fault in a mystery scrum penalty in the 26th minute, but otherwise got good return from the scrums, where the All Blacks might have felt referee Nic Berry did
them few favours. Was accurate in his tackling and did well when he got on the end of that drive for the glimmer-of-hope try at the end of the first half.

2. Codie Taylor (c) – 3

Taylor’s tidy work in the shunt from the attacking lineout drive that put de Groot over the line was handy and he was busy in defence, clocking up 13 tackles in first half. He also bagged an important early turnover.

But the lineouts were a mess. The stand-in skipper’s work must be considered as pillar lineout moments went pear shaped: His first throw of the match caught Fabian Holland unawares, and the first two of the second half also went straight into English mitts. The England machine don’t need free hits in a set piece where their proficiency and confidence is already high.

The All Blacks needed their veteran leader to rally the troops in the frantic first-half efforts to get a skerrick of possession.

Dejected All Blacks at full time. Photo / Photosport
Dejected All Blacks at full time. Photo / Photosport

3. Fletcher Newell – 3

Won an important scrum penalty in the 19th minute – back in the good old days when the All Blacks still seemed a chance of winning this test. Newell fumbled the ball when filling in at halfback at a ruck just outside the All Blacks’ 22, and should have got something on Ellis Genge in the Englishman’s 61st-minute charge that led directly to the hosts fifth try.

4. Scott Barrett – 2

The former captain getting absolutely snotted by flanker Ollie Chessum in the 76th minute pretty much summed up the All Blacks’ night. He was crabbing sideways at the time (as his teammates had done all night) and spilled the ball in the hit.

5. Fabian Holland – 4

Seemed unaware and unready when he fudged the first attacking lineout ball in 13th minute. The big Dutchman was part of an utterly neutered All Blacks lineout, barely getting off his feet on England ball.

His 13 carries were the most of any All Black, but still a chucklesome 20 behind England’s Ben Earl. Holland was the preferred middle-of-the-park target man with the visitors hoping to punch holes around him. It was in this role that his good hands helped set up the space when Beauden Barrrett scored.

Fabian Holland helped to set up Beauden Barrett's try. Photo / Photosport
Fabian Holland helped to set up Beauden Barrett’s try. Photo / Photosport

6. Tupou Vaa’i – 3

The second rower did excellent work to get beneath an England tryline surge in the 24th minute. Vaa’i couldn’t find the space to make his size count out wide and spilled the ball on a rare half chance on the right flank.

He left the field after a terrible (and bizarrely unpunished) head knock from Maro Itoje in the 55th minute, meaning the All Blacks two locks had to run for the full 80 minutes.

7. Peter Lakai – 4

The All Blacks opensider made 13 first-half tackles, but in the black No 7 jersey it’s the ones you miss that linger – like when he got dragged into a post-scrum pile up so was unavailable to halt Ben Earl as he scored England’s third try.

Lakai was busy at the breakdowns throughout the Good work and vision in build up to Beauden Barrett’s try.

8. Wallace Sititi – 5

Despite Sititi being among the All Blacks’ best on a grim afternoon in London, they might rue not having a classic fetcher on the field in the first half, when the ball seemed forever out of reach. Nonetheless, the No 8 did what he could, completing 21 tackles and 12 carries, few of which budged the English line. Massively overshadowed by his opposite number, Ben Earl.

9. Cam Roigard – 3

A scratchy night from the All Blacks highly rated halfback, who booted the ball plenty, and often without enough accuracy. His strange option to tap then boot on a defensive penalty in the ninth minute brought back memories of last year’s defeat, when the All Blacks seemed clueless about the basics. Brutally bumped off by Ben Earl.

10. Damien McKenzie – 3

On defence, the All Blacks first five-eighths got floored by a couple of big runners, but typically bounced back. More importantly, he was drawn off his line at key moments, like when England scored on their first grubber kick and when he went in the wrong direction in the build up to England’s fourth try.

On attack, he didn’t bother England at all. Missed a handy (and badly needed) conversion from de Groot’s try.

11. Josh Moorby – 3

Seldom seen on an evening when primary work for both starting wingers seemed to be desperately hanging onto the ball after teammates further infield had flung it frantically in their direction.

12. Jordie Barrett – 3

Made an early knock on leaping for a high ball, then conceded the game’s first penalty in the third minute, slipping over as he went for the ball at a ruck. Things didn’t improve much from there, though he did get through a pile of defensive work.

13. Anton Lienert-Brown – 2

His coach praised the veteran’s defensive efforts the week before in Cardiff – which seemed odd, given the defeat to Wales marked only the second time a Home Nations side had put five tries past the All Blacks. (The third time? This match.)

Lienert-Brown was caught flatfooted when England made a clean break through his outside channel in 15th minute. From there, the English smell blood, targetting the space outside ALB relentlessly. A 30th-minute break in his outside channel in the lead up to England’s second try was particularly telling.

14. Will Jordan – 4

Tough night with few chances for a little winger. Jordan overran a pass on a good opportunity in the 25th minute. Soon after, his smart kick set up the lineout strike from which the visitors scored their first try just before halftime. He was off with a limp in the 51st minute.

15. Beauden Barrett – 3

AWOL, possibly pinned beneath an English forward, when the hosts scored their first try with a grubber over the All Blacks tryline, the sesquicentennial fullback was largely off the pace in this frantic scrambling match. In one notable moment of discombobulation, Barrett fed a dopey pass directly to an England player in a rare foray into the line. From that wayward 44th-minute pass a passage of play ensued with roughly a gazillion phases by both teams, before he popped up to bag the All Blacks second – utterly futile – score.

Bench

16. Asafo Aumua – 1

The match was a disaster before Aumua’s 55th-minute arrival on the field, but he didn’t help. His first lineout went straight into Pommy hands, and he left a generous gap for Ellis Genge to run through in the build up to Atkinson’s try. Was right at hand when Cam Roigard took the ball into contact in the 65th minute, but possession was lost because Aumua was too slow to act.

17. George Bower – 3

Showed good hands, flicking on to second runners. But his name can be added to the list of All Blacks falttened by Genge on a woeful night.

18. Pasilio Tosi – 2

Put his knee to the ground to concede a 73rd-minute scrum penalty, at right about the time many All Blacks fans were kneeling and praying.

19. Anton Segner – 4

Ran brightly in wide channel where he replaced Vai’i, looking for long passes and kicks. Stole a late lineout right on his line, which might not have looked so smart if an Englishman had gotten on the end of the tap ball, but the effort was appreciated. Don’t worry too much, mate – being an All Black gets better than this.

20. Leicester Fainga’anuku – 2

Heavily hyped hybrid came on as a midfielder with little return.

21. Cortez Ratima – 2

Lost possession on his second touch of the ball trying to crib a few yards in Roigard fashion.

22. Richie Mo’unga – 3

Tokyo currently looking pretty good.

23. Rieko Ioane – 3

On as a winger in the 52nd minute and got straight into a lot of tidying up and scrambling. There were a couple of backpedalling errors for another who could find no space on the flank.

Winston Aldworth is Head of Sport for NZME, working alongside New Zealand’s best sports journalists in the radio and publishing teams.

Gift article

Save

Share

    Share this article

    Reminder, this is a Premium article and requires a subscription to read.

  • Copy Link
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter/X
  • LinkedIn
  • Reddit

More in Sports

View all

Latest news